JakartaPost-Mar 27
The signing of the Agreement on Reciprocal Trade (ART) between Indonesia and the United States on Feb. 19 has raised serious concern regarding the erosion of sovereignty in Indonesia’s foreign policymaking. By requiring Indonesia to align its domestic regulations with Washington’s security interests, the ART does more than just compromise Jakarta’s “free and active” doctrine; it tarnishes ASEAN’s collective reputation as a zone of peace, freedom and neutrality amid escalating great power rivalry. The ability of Southeast Asian nations to navigate global competition has traditionally rested on two pillars: a persistent refusal to “take sides” and a commitment to regional unity in the face of external pressure. However, nearly a year after the US first announced its global tariff strategy on April 2, 2025, those pillars have begun to fracture. The varied responses to the ART framework demonstrate a growing willingness among member states to sacrifice regional solidarity for individual economic survival. This fracture did not occur overnight. Initially, ASEAN’s response showed signs of resilience. Just a week after the 2025 tariff announcement, the bloc issued a joint statement asserting “open economic regionalism” and established the ASEAN Geoeconomic Taskforce under the Malaysian chairmanship. These moves highlighted the grouping’s adaptive ability to manage the growing economic-security nexus. However, as geoeconomic headwinds intensified, it became clear that pragmatism frequently trumps idealism. The indispensability of the US market forced Indonesia and its neighbors to consider non-reciprocal concessions to save their export-dependent economies. Competitive pressure—specifically from fellow ASEAN members who rely on the same manufacturing exports—prevented collective action. Instead of a unified front, nations opted for bilateral negotiations to secure better deals than their regional competitors, even when such deals demanded a compromise of their neutrality. Read more at:
https://www.thejakartapost.com/opinion/2026/03/27/geoeconomic-headwinds-fracture-asean-neutrality.html?utm_source=(direct)&utm_medium=home_opinion
